Hopefully you’ve now got a better idea about what you want out of a theme and what you want from plugins for your church site. Now it’s time to find a good theme to build off of. Of course, everyone’s answer will be different to this question based on the purpose of their site and the appearance they want to give off.
For example, a more traditional church who is looking to serve its current congregation may answer this very differently to a more contemporary church who are looking to inform and attract potential visitors of the church.
However, there are a few popular providers of church specific themes and WordPress themes that you might want to check out.